Kelly's Farm Market Inc

“I am SO overdue for leaving this review, so I apologize to the business and general public for holding back for so long. I love this place. They have THE BEST apple crisp and fried cakes. This is a place I'm sure to always go to each autumn season, at least a few times a month. I used to come here as a kid and now that I have a daughter, I am upholding the same yearly tradition. Thank you so much Kelly's farm market! We love you all”

“This is location on wilder rd in Hilton New York. The parking is safe and clean. They are finally opened for the season and there dounts and cider are unbelievable yummy. Great job to all the employees and owners who make delicious Desserts. Gerry”

“I love the smell of cider when you walk in. I always make sure to get their apple crisp, it’s the best!😊the employees are wonderful.the picnic tables and benches on the side are nice to sit and relax.”

“Our families favorite place. The little ones are so fascinated with the apple cider press. They love to taste the free apple cider samples while eating the fresh made donuts!”

“This place is definitely for all ages. I love that they have a cozy fireplace with seating. Whatever desert you choose, will be delicious. You can get monster size cookies, strudels, pies, etc. They have delicious cider and honey as well. There are plenty of photo opportunities on the farm-flowers, pumpkins, tractors, etc and it's free. The lines are long but the cashiers are wicked fast.”

“Myself and my family went out to kelly's saturday morning at 10 a m as we do every year . It's a family tradition started by my late father sixty years ago.. first things first, we went in and got our donuts, and then went to get our cider, and there wasn't any.. Shocked I went up to the staff and asked where's the cider, and she rudely told me we can't keep up with demand.. A Saturday morning in season at 10 AM. And you had no apple cider, available at an apple farm.. To say we were pissed off is an understatement.. Kelly's, this is a seasonal business.We expect more out of you than what you provided yesterday. Very very disappointed. One staff member also said it would be ready in about a half hour. Half hour came and went no cider. Please do better next time!! Also a close friend went to the Hilton Apple fest, and there was plenty of kelly's apple cider, there!!”

“My mother and father in law always get donuts and bread for the kids and us from here. They are usually amazing! But this time around I’m disappointed in the donuts. Most of them were cooked, but the one I just ate tonight was undercooked on the inside. So much raw dough I just ate I’m thankful it was me and not one of the kids. (I took pics of the pieces I had left when I finally realized why the donut was so moist and gooey. Hopefully I don’t end up sick from this. Just wanted to share so that way whoever has been recently making the donuts can maybe just be aware. Mistakes happen, but hopefully no one else gets any like this and hopefully no one else ends up sick.”

“Update November 2025 Who shrunk the pies? Cider and honey are great. Pies are good but you may want to consider another place for pies. Rustic inside. We have been ordering pies from here for many years. Ordered apple pies again. They shrunk the size of the pies by about 35%... now it's the size of a pie from Wegmans. Aside from the taste, the size set Kelly's apart from all other pie makers. We were all very disappointed to receive these SMALLER PIES. They said nothing about this when placing our order. For 20 years or more, the pies were huge. Not any more. We don't think we will order them again. I guess they did this to cut their costs... too bad. We talked with others in Hilton who said the same thing. Also, $2 for a fry cake donut... Wow... way too expensive! We hope Jamie (the owner) will revert back to their original size pies. If not, no more pies from Kelly's for us and fewer visits to buy their goods. Disappointed! Decreased star rating for this pie change. This is a long establised family owned cider mill and bakery. The have other things including thei own honey produced in their own bee hives. Outstanding, cider, donuts, baked goods, pies and honey. The donuts have gotten very pricey at $2 each which is too much! Highly recomended.”