Farm visit · Mexico, New York
Molly Johns Farm, LLC
Molly Johns Farm, LLC open today
Molly Johns Farm, LLC is a farm visit destination in Mexico, New York, useful for seasonal produce, stands, and agri-tourism stops. Rated 4.9 from 37 reviews. Confirm hours before you go.
About this farm
Molly Johns Farm, LLC is a farm visit destination in Mexico, New York, useful for seasonal produce, stands, and agri-tourism stops.
Visitors commonly come for christmas trees.
It holds a 4.9 rating across 37 public reviews.
Today (Saturday) is listed as 10 AM–5 PM. Hours can change with harvest and weather.
Location
Find Molly Johns Farm, LLC at 4239 NY-69, Mexico, NY 13114, United States. Plus Code: CQXF+RW Mexico, New York, USA.
4239 NY-69 , Mexico , New York 13114 , US
Hours
Local time (America/New_York). Hours can change with harvest and weather — confirm before you go.
10 AM–5 PM
Monday
9 AM–2 PM
Tuesday
9 AM–2 PM
Wednesday
9 AM–2 PM
Thursday
9 AM–2 PM
Friday
9 AM–2 PM
Saturday · today
10 AM–5 PM
Sunday
10 AM–5 PM
What you can pick
In October, check what’s currently ripe before you go. Seasons below are typical windows for New York, not a guarantee for this exact farm.
Before you go
A short checklist so the trip feels easy — especially helpful for first-time u-pick visits in New York.
- Check whether this stop is a stand, orchard tour, or full farm experience before you arrive.
- Call or check the website for today’s picking conditions — mud, rain, and sold-out fields are common.
- Arrive earlier in the day for cooler weather and better selection during peak weekends.
- Cash still helps at smaller stands even when cards are accepted.
Amenities & details
Attributes pulled from the listing data. Confirm anything important (pets, accessibility, payments) with the farm.
Service options
- • On-site services
Accessibility
- • Wheelchair-accessible car park
- • Wheelchair-accessible entrance
Amenities
- • Toilet
Payments
- • Credit cards
- • Debit cards
Photos
4 photos from the listing plus visitor snaps below in reviews. Click any item for a full preview — videos play in the viewer.
What visitors say
37 reviews on file · showing 8 visitor notes from the listing data.
![]()
“After an unsuccessful attempt at purchasing a small local Christmas tree where the results ranged from "rude" to really expensive we stopped at Molly Johns. The folks there immediately got us a beautiful small tree at an incredible price. I had never been in the shop and was so pleasantly surprised by the items there and how helpful the folks were. I am heading back to do some Christmas shopping.”
![]()
“They have a fantastic selection of live trees. Cutting your own couldn't be easier. And they'll bring it back for you and wrap it if that is what you need. Need to warm up? No problem. They have a really nice outdoor fireplace and another inside as well. Coffee and hot cocoa are available to warm you on the inside. This is our second year getting a tree here and I think we'll be back for sure.”
![]()
“We rented Molly-John’s farm for an engagement celebration and couldn’t be any happier with the party! The venue was perfect for 80 + people. Many guests complimented the event! We had it catered. Their venue offers a special ambiance, many different extra items that made catering there a breeze plus stylish. Thank you Molly-John’s!!!”
![]()
![]()
“This is an amazing family-owned business. They have a cute and cozy shop that had a hot chocolate bar and so many cute activities for children too! They had donkeys, who were super friendly and patient with our kids. They also hand-make beautiful wreaths!”
![]()
![]()
“We have found a true diamond! Molly John's has it all. Trees, animals, gift shop, wreaths, dried arrangements, blueberries, curly willow, mums... every season is taken care of! LOVE, LOVE, LOVE!”
![]()
![]()
“An excellent place to get your Christmas tree. There's a shop with lots of decor and a room with a fireplace where hot cocoa and treats are served. Everyone there was welcoming and helpful.”
![]()
![]()
“Did some Christmas shopping, enjoyed the decor very much and loved feeding the donkeys!”
![]()
![]()
“We stopped in to their shop today. My wife found them via the Mexico chamber of commerce website. The outside of the building has plenty of parking. The outside of the building was also very well decorated, which is continued inside. Once you enter though, it gets a little confusing. There are several large seating areas in the corner, as well as what must be a 10 or 12 foot dining table with accompanied seating, right in the middle of the first room. In the one side of the table there are several nice things for sale, though the prices are a bit on the high side. Not completely overpriced but a small percentage more than can be found at similar shops. Beyond the first room there is a second very open room with nothing but seating around a very large fireplace. It is unclear if this shop is more of a living space for the owners with things for sale or is simply a work in progress. The entire place is very well decorated, magazine photo worthy in fact. The staff were very polite as well. Overall, I believe they are a worthy shop to visit.”
![]()
FAQ
Is this a u-pick farm?
It may be a farm stand, orchard visit, or agri-tourism stop. Check the website or call ahead for picking rules.
Where is Molly Johns Farm, LLC?
4239 NY-69, Mexico, NY 13114, United States Plus Code CQXF+RW Mexico, New York, USA.
What are today’s hours?
Saturday: 10 AM–5 PM. Full weekly hours are listed above.
Is it accessible?
Listing notes include: Wheelchair-accessible car park, Wheelchair-accessible entrance. Field paths can still be uneven — ask the farm about current conditions.
How do I get there?
Use the Directions button for turn-by-turn navigation to 43.44953, -76.22525. Street View is also linked above so you can preview the entrance.
More u-pick near Mexico
If this stop is closed or picked out, these nearby listings are within roughly a short drive.
Appledale Orchards
Mexico, New York
Behling Orchards
Mexico, New York
Uncle Eric's U-Pick it Blueberries
Parish, New York
Parish Pumpkin Patch
Parish, New York
Guppy's Berry Farm
West Monroe, New York
Stan's Berry Patch
West Monroe, New York