Jericho Cider Mill

“The Jericho Cider Mill has been an absolute staple for years, and it’s easy to see why it remains a local favorite. Walking in always feels nostalgic, welcoming, and, best of all, smells incredible. If you haven’t tried their frapples yet, you are seriously missing out—they are the perfect, refreshing treat and worth the trip alone. Their selection of desserts is equally outstanding, from the rich, flaky pies to their famous cider donuts that are always perfectly spiced. Whether you’ve been coming here for decades or are stopping by for the first time, it’s a wonderful community gem that delivers top-tier quality every single time. Highly recommended!”

“Our first trip here. A gold mine. A treasure. It is very hard to give a rating of 5 from me. This place deserves it. First, the greeting of the workers. The young girl that cash is out was so happy. Genuinely ready to help out. The apple cider slushy with a pump of butterscotch was absolutely delicious. The cheesecake and coconut custard pie were so good. I cried. Can't wait to go back to try their other deliciousness. The prices are worth it when it comes to quality and quantity. A must stop for apple lovers.”

“We loved our visit to Jericho Cider Mill! The cider slushie and fresh donuts were amazing, and the apple cranberry crumb was the perfect sweet finish. You can really feel the history and family tradition here. Great fall vibes, friendly service, and such a beautiful spot to relax and enjoy the season.”

“Cycled by here for 2 years now and first time I actually saw the sign “Apple Cider.” Guess we were cycling too fast at 30 mph. Made a quick U turn and decided to grab an apple cider donut too. The donuts come packed 5 in a bag. The apple cider comes in a frozen slush or plastic container in the fridge. Both were good 👍. Although the sign outside said made fresh. It doesn’t say “Made fresh daily.” So not really sure how fresh the products actually are… The shop offers many other items. Ice cream looks to be popular as it’s ubiquitous. A few outdoor bench seats makes it good for a family outing or friends. I ate 3 donuts and had to tie the other 2 with a plastic bag to my bicycle 🚴. REVIEWER SUGGESTION: 1) offer 2 donuts in a pack for $3 2) put some baked items on display in glass counter 3) emphasize if “Baked Fresh Daily””

“Took the drive out to experience the hype- warning, parking is limited so we were on the side of the road. Donuts were delicious (though we hoped to get them warm). Bought a half gallon of cider for home along with a strawberry jam and a hot cider to go with the donuts. All were great and I'd encourage you to stop by and shop local.”

“Almost missed this place, thanks to the flags which called my attention. Off the road, no parking so just parked on the side of the road. No sidewalk, just raised uneven grassy area - not wheelchair accessible. Store is small, filled with a variety of jarred products (don’t know if it was just that day but they weren’t organized by label), pies, donuts, bottled cider, etc. Got a gallon of cider, a bag of donuts and a frozen cider (a slushy version). Hot cider was also available. I liked their donut- cakey but not as dense as others I’ve had, just the right sweetness. Apples and pumpkins on sale, some photo ops outside.”

“Cider and donuts were a hit. Pies were below average. We ordered a peach and apple pie. The peach pie was clearly made with canned peaches during the peak of peach season, and the crust on both pies were underbaked and not soggy. We ended up throwing out the pies.”

“Honestly, the service here is extremely horrible. They don’t help with any questions and cut you off. Older, blonde woman there was extremely rude & shouldn’t be working service. Maybe she was having an off day but I feel that with her age, she should have some type of emotional maturity not to bring it to work. The cider donut was a bit dry as well. Location wise- located next to busy road so be careful when parking.”